Tamil Nadu has removed 70,674 suspect books, many of them alleged to be AI-generated, from its public libraries and suspended five library officials. On Monday the state's anti-corruption agency searched the Chennai home of the publisher at the centre of the case, The South First reported.
For authors who use AI, the case is about provenance more than tools. The books were flagged for invented authors, wrong facts and doubtful ISBNs, and a state government is now treating those failures as a possible crime.
What changed since the court order
When EntangledText first reported the case on November 11, the Madras High Court had just ordered the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register a criminal case and freeze bank accounts belonging to Agal Vilakku Publications and its proprietor, Mohan.
On Monday, November 16, DVAC officers searched Mohan's residence in Madipakkam, Chennai, according to The South First. The court had given the agency four days to register an FIR and told the library department to produce its procurement records by November 16.
The day before, the state suspended five senior officials of the Directorate of Public Libraries, The News Minute and The New Indian Express reported. They are S Kamatchi and S Santhana Karthikeyan of the Anna Centenary Library in Chennai, Dinesh Kumar and V Santhanakrishnan of the Kalaignar Centenary Library in Madurai, and J Juliet, the directorate's chief accounts officer.
Two of them sat on the committee that negotiated prices with publishers. The department has not published the inquiry order behind the suspensions or its findings, both outlets noted. DT Next reported that DVAC was expected to file a report with the High Court on Monday and described the suspensions as a first step toward an FIR.
From 1,800 books to 70,674
The case began when Tamil writer Perumal Murugan flagged nearly 1,800 questionable titles from Agal Vilakku and more than 100 from a publisher called Phoenix 2023 at the new Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore, according to The News Minute.
Inspections over the following week identified 70,674 suspect books worth an estimated Rs 7 crore (70 million rupees) across the state's public libraries, DT Next reported, adding that the count could rise. The New Indian Express put the figure at around 71,000 and said more than 300 questionable books had turned up at the Madurai library, which bought them in 2022.
The purchases covered five large Arivulagam libraries and six new district libraries, with around Rs 190 crore allocated, according to DT Next. A process that normally takes about six months was reportedly completed in 30 days. The High Court recorded that Agal Vilakku was paid Rs 17 lakh for 1,700 titles, while the established Chennai publisher Kizhakku Pathippagam received an order worth Rs 23,000.
Kizhakku founder Badri Seshadri told DT Next he suspected the titles were inserted at the final approval stage, pointing to the five-member High-Level Committee rather than the 137-member panel of writers and scholars.
The AI part is still unproven
School Education Minister A Rajmohan has called the affair potentially "India's first AI scam," the BBC reported. The same report was careful on the central point: "It remains unclear whether AI was used to produce any of the disputed books."
What is documented is simpler and easier to check. One book in a Madurai library named the economist Jean Drèze as its author, and Drèze told The Hindu he had not written it, according to the BBC. Others misattributed classical Tamil works. Mohan declined to comment to the BBC, saying the matter was before the courts.
That makes the Tamil Nadu case different from the dispute in Norway, where a 72.5 percent detector score was enough to put Jørn Lier Horst's bestseller on trial in the press. Here the evidence is fake bylines and factual errors that any reader with a reference shelf could verify.
What it means for authors who use AI
Public buyers in two countries are now setting terms. Arts Council Norway (Kulturrådet) has said that from 2027 it will not buy or fund books "wholly or partly produced by artificial intelligence." Tamil Nadu has cancelled every book order placed so far and promised a more transparent purchasing policy, The New Indian Express reported.
For writers who draft with AI and sell to libraries, the exposure lies in the failures named in the Indian complaints. A real author name, a valid ISBN and facts that survive a check now carry legal weight. An invented historical detail is the kind of error that started this inquiry.
Records matter too. Horst defended himself with his own account of how he used ChatGPT. In Tamil Nadu, DT Next noted that comparing the committees' original recommendations with the final catalogue, portal logins and edit timestamps could show whether titles were added late.
Four of the five Arivulagam libraries, in Tiruchy, Salem, Cuddalore and Tirunelveli, have not yet opened. Their book orders are among those the minister cancelled.
Sources
- DVAC searches Agal Vilakku Publications proprietor's residence over alleged irregularities in library book purchases — The South First,
- TN govt suspends five library officials over AI book scam — The News Minute,
- Five TN library officials suspended over alleged irregularities in book procurement for government libraries — The New Indian Express,
- DVAC may register FIRs soon, likely to submit report to High Court — DT Next,
- Not by the book: 70,674 suspect titles, 30-day shortcut purchase — DT Next,
- New Indian mega library rocked by scandal over 'AI-generated books' — BBC News,
Every quotation and figure in this article is checked against the source reporting linked above before publication. How we report
