Irish Writers Union tells lawmakers AI firms bought 2 million used books to scan and shred

The same week, Australia's authors and publishers were among 36 groups launching Not AI's to Take, a petition demanding permission and payment before any AI training.

Key points

  • The Irish Writers Union told an Oireachtas committee that tech firms bought around two million used books to scan and destroy for AI training.
  • Australian authors and publishers joined 36 groups behind Not AI's to Take, a petition demanding permission and payment before AI training.
  • Both push toward rules separating human and AI-assisted books, similar to the AI-generated and AI-assisted split KDP already uses.

The Irish Writers Union told an Oireachtas committee on Tuesday that technology companies have bought around two million books from second-hand and antique booksellers, cut them apart for scanning and thrown the paper away to train AI models. In Australia the same week, the Australian Society of Authors and the Australian Publishers Association were among 36 organisations behind Not AI's to Take, a national campaign demanding permission and payment before Australian work is used for AI training.

Both put the same demand to governments: AI developers should ask before training on books, pay for them and disclose what they took. The Irish testimony also pushes toward labels separating fully human books from AI-assisted ones.

"AI scan factories"

Conor Kostick, who appeared for the Irish Writers Union and the European Writers' Council, told the Joint Committee on Artificial Intelligence that old, rare and out-of-commerce titles are "subject to bulk scanning and being destroyed in the process," RTÉ reported. He said that in what he called "AI scan factories" in the US, spines are cut off so pages can be fed through high-speed scanners, and the remaining copy is "discarded, shredded, and recycled into toilet paper."

"Many such books will never be found again and will exist solely as the digital property of an AI tech company," Kostick said, according to RTÉ. He told the committee that UNESCO considers the systematic destruction of books a "serious breach of the Hague Convention".

The practice he described is on the court record in the US. Judge William Alsup's June 2025 fair use ruling in Bartz v. Anthropic set out how Anthropic bought print books in bulk, stripped the bindings, scanned the pages and discarded the originals, Ars Technica reported. Alsup found that scanning lawfully purchased copies was fair use. Ars noted the documents did not indicate any rare books were destroyed, and reports from Dublin did not say which companies Kostick's figure covered.

Kostick also told TDs and Senators there has been a "tsunami of books published by AI, and that's only going to get worse," The Irish Times reported. RTÉ reported his claim, not independently checked, that around half a million AI books on Amazon are being "passed off" as human-written.

Authorisation, remuneration, transparency

The union is pushing the European Writers' Council's principles of authorisation, remuneration and transparency. "Authors must retain the freedom to say no. Offering payment after the fact is no substitute for taking away that fundamental right," Kostick said in a statement published by Writing.ie.

It cited Trinity College Dublin research that it said found more than 30 recent AI models had not filed the transparency submissions the EU AI Act requires. The committee also heard that AI-generated imitations of novels, poems and essays do not have to be labelled, RTÉ reported. Kostick said books that are 100% human-made should be distinguishable from AI-assisted books.

Australia's campaign targets an opt-out

The Australian petition calls on Parliament to "keep existing copyright protections in place." ArtsHub listed 36 backers, including the Australian Literary Agents Association, with authors Anna Funder and Trent Dalton among supporters. Books+Publishing put the petition at more than 1,200 signatures on Tuesday. The campaign's own site showed 6,515 on Wednesday morning.

The Albanese government ruled out a text and data mining exception in October 2025. Its announcement said such an exception would have let AI developers use Australian creators' works "for free and without permission to train AI systems." The campaign says other options are still being considered, including an opt-out model in which work could be used unless a creator says no. The Guardian reported that Anthropic has put forward an opt-out model in Australia.

At Wednesday's ARIA Awards in Sydney, Elton John backed the campaign in a pre-recorded message. "Don't let AI use any Australian artist's work without full permission," he said, The Guardian reported. A spokesperson for Attorney-General Michelle Rowland told Guardian Australia that any copyright changes would "deliver meaningful control and fair compensation."

What it means for authors who use AI

Neither event changes the law yet, but both point toward rules that reach writers who draft or edit with AI. Amazon's Kindle Direct Publishing guidelines already require authors to disclose AI-generated text, images and translations, while AI-assisted work such as editing or brainstorming needs no disclosure. A legal line between 100% human and AI-assisted books, as Kostick proposed, would put a similar split into law. Authors who keep notes on how they used AI would be better placed under either.

Consent rules would shape the tools themselves. If Australia keeps permission-first copyright, developers training there would need licences, which favours tools built on licensed or disclosed data. The same pressure ran through our coverage of the Society of Authors quitting the ethical AI charter it launched and the report that Anthropic downloaded pirated Han Kang novels.

In the US, the training question now sits with Judge Sidney Stein in the consolidated OpenAI copyright case, where reply briefs on fair use are due on 20 November, AI Weekly reported, with no date set for argument.

Sources

  1. AI firms turning books into toilet paper, committee told — RTÉ,
  2. Irish artists raise concerns over 'industrial extraction' of work to train AI — The Irish Times,
  3. Irish Authors Demand Urgent AI Regulation — Writing.ie,
  4. Australian Society of Authors, Australian Publishers Association among orgs launching Not AI's to Take campaign — Books+Publishing,
  5. Not AI's to Take: arts, screen and media sectors join forces to protect creatives from AI theft — ArtsHub,
  6. Elton John backs Australian artists in fight against AI in surprise Aria awards appearance — The Guardian,
  7. Not AI's to Take: Protect Australian Creativity — Not AI's to Take
  8. Albanese Government to ensure Australia is prepared for future copyright challenges emerging from AI — Attorney-General's portfolio,
  9. Anthropic destroyed millions of print books to build its AI models — Ars Technica,
  10. Judge Stein approves 56 amicus briefs in OpenAI copyright case — AI Weekly

Every quotation and figure in this article is checked against the source reporting linked above before publication. How we report