Tor pulls Ilona Andrews cover after finding generative AI despite no-AI clauses on both sides

Two artists' Instagram comments flagged the art. Andrews now plans to demand project files for every commissioned painting, and also ended a vertical drama deal over AI.

Key points

  • Tor withdrew the This Crown Will Not Rule Me cover after confirming generative AI was used, though both the author contract and art contract banned AI.
  • Ilona Andrews plans to request project files for all commissioned art and ended a vertical drama deal over that company's AI use.
  • KDP requires self-publishers to disclose AI-generated cover images, so authors commissioning covers carry the same verification risk.

Tor Publishing Group has pulled the newly revealed cover of Ilona Andrews' fantasy novel This Crown Will Not Rule Me after learning that generative AI was used to make the art. Both the authors' book contract and Tor's art contracts already banned AI, which means a no-AI clause alone did not stop AI imagery from reaching a major publisher's cover reveal.

The authors, who now say they may demand project files for every commissioned painting, published Tor's statement on the Ilona Andrews blog on November 20. Tor also told readers on Facebook that it had taken the cover down, File 770 reported.

"Tor Publishing Group has learned that generative AI was used in the creation of the cover art for This Crown Will Not Rule Me, without the knowledge of either Tor or of the authors," the statement says. Tor said it is "taking down the recently revealed cover design and will not be using this imagery on any completed books."

The publisher accepted the blame. "Tor takes full responsibility for the breakdown in our review process," the statement says, adding: "To be clear, this is on us, not the authors." Tor said it will be "bolstering our internal review processes" and will share a new cover "as soon as we can." It gave no date for the replacement.

Readers and two artists caught it

According to the blog post, readers raised concerns about possible AI-generated elements as soon as the cover was released. The authors notified Tor, "asked for the proof of human-created art, and settled down to wait."

The post credits two artists, Markova and Zakuga Art, for Instagram comments that "alerted us to this issue." The authors added: "This would not have been caught without your help."

Neither Tor nor the authors named the cover artist. The post asks fans: "Please don't flame the artist on social media."

The authors also explained why their usual checks failed. "In this case, the cover was commissioned by our publisher, and a sketch was provided to the art department. It looked like a typical cover sketch," they wrote.

From vetting artists to vetting files

The proposed fix is more paperwork for illustrators. "We may have to request project files for review. We will be doing that for all of our commissioned work going forward," the post says. "We can no longer vet the artist. We have to vet every individual painting."

The same post disclosed a second AI problem. Earlier this year the authors signed with a vertical drama company after specifying no AI and only human actors and writers, then found that "the level of generative AI involved in the company's other productions did not align with our preferences." They have terminated that contract.

Tor has been here before

This is not the first AI cover dispute at Tor. In December 2022, the publisher said a stock image on the cover of Christopher Paolini's Fractal Noise may have been AI-made, Kirkus Reviews reported. Tor kept that cover, saying: "Due to production constraints, we have decided to move ahead with the current cover."

In February 2024, Publishers Weekly reported that the cover of Gothikana by RuNyx, from Tor's romance imprint Bramble, used two Adobe Stock images flagged on Adobe's site as "generated with AI."

Both earlier cases involved stock art. This one involved a commissioned illustration under a contract that banned AI, and this time Tor pulled the image before it reached finished books.

Publishers do not all respond the same way. As Entangled Text reported on November 13, Paizo kept the art in its Pathfinder book Feybound after its artist denied using AI.

What it means for authors who use AI

Self-published authors act as their own art department, and Amazon puts the disclosure duty on them. KDP's content guidelines require authors to report AI-generated content when they publish, and say "AI-generated images include cover and interior images and artwork." AI-assisted work does not need to be disclosed.

A writer who pays for a cover and does not know the artist used a generator could tick the wrong box. Asking for layered files or work-in-progress stages, as the Andrews team now plans to do, gives a self-publisher something to check before uploading.

The episode also shows how strict some readerships are. Andrews' readers flagged the art from the reveal alone, before any book shipped. For authors who use AI openly in drafting, the cover is often the first place readers look for it.

Other tool makers are drawing the line with opt-ins rather than bans. This week Vellum restored its Automation feature, which connects ChatGPT or Claude to bulk formatting tasks, behind a settings switch that authors must turn on, Indie Author Magazine reported. West, one of Vellum's three-person team, told the magazine that about one in five emails the team received opposed the feature.

Disclosure is becoming a contract term on the publishing side too. As Entangled Text reported on November 15, German publisher Rowohlt cancelled a translated novel over its author's undisclosed use of generative AI.

On Entangled Text

  • AI Comic Studio: turn a story or script into comic pages with panel art and speech bubbles.
  • AI Manga Generator: turn a story into manga pages or a vertical webtoon.

Sources

  1. Generative AI on This Crown's Cover — Ilona Andrews,
  2. Pixel Scroll 11/20/26 — File 770,
  3. Cover of Paolini Book May Contain AI-Created Image — Kirkus Reviews,
  4. Tor Books Criticized for Use of AI-Generated Art in 'Gothikana' Cover Design — Publishers Weekly,
  5. Vellum Gives Authors the Option to Automatically Update Formats Across Titles, Again — Indie Author Magazine,

Every quotation and figure in this article is checked against the source reporting linked above before publication. How we report