Prix Goncourt winner Philippe Jaenada admits he used ChatGPT while writing his novel

The admission came a day after he collected the prize, whose jury had removed another book from its longlist over suspected AI use.

Key points

  • Philippe Jaenada won the Prix Goncourt for L'Inconnue du quai de Javel and told France Inter he used AI three times in writing it.
  • The Académie Goncourt had removed Thélyson Orélien's novel from its longlist in September over suspected AI use.
  • Orélien denied the allegations, then his Canadian publisher Boréal said evidence showed AI was used and ended their relationship.

The winner of France's most prestigious literary prize has said he used artificial intelligence while writing his novel, a day after collecting an award whose jury had removed another book from its longlist over suspected AI use.

Philippe Jaenada won the Prix Goncourt on Tuesday for L'Inconnue du quai de Javel (The Unknown Woman of the Quai de Javel). He told France Inter radio on Wednesday that he had turned to AI three times in the course of the work, The Guardian reported.

One use, he said, was to slip in a sentence written by ChatGPT in order to play with the reader. He said he had told the Goncourt jurors which sentence it was only on the day of the award, and that if it got out he would know where it had come from.

He also put a section of AI-generated text into the book to make fun of ChatGPT, which he said had given completely absurd answers about a technical detail, and he used the tool for research.

"I don't think AI can be held back. We can't pretend it doesn't exist," said Jaenada, 62. "You have to use it – but first you have to acknowledge it, and above all you have to tame it. It has to be useful."

Jaenada had defended his use of AI before the award. In an interview with 20 Minutes he asked whether a film director would hide the fact that he uses special effects, and predicted it would soon be impossible to say a text was entirely human-written. He insisted AI would never be able to write a book with its heart, its soul, its memories.

A longlist removal, then a prize

His admission follows the Académie Goncourt's decision to remove Thélyson Orélien's C'était ça ou Mourir (It Was That or Die) from its longlist in September. The Canadian-Haitian writer's debut had been the breakout hit of France's rentrée littéraire, the period between late August and early November when many books are published in France. It sold more than 35,000 copies and won the Prix du roman Fnac before the journalist Samuel Fitoussi ran it through the AI-detection tool Pangram and concluded that much of it had been machine-generated.

The accuracy of AI-detection software has been called into question. In a statement on 25 September, the academy said analyses by researchers and journalists showed the novel was in all likelihood very largely the product of an artificial intelligence. It said it wanted to protect the integrity of a prize that exists to honour literature written by women and men, and to send a clear message that it did not endorse texts generated with the help of AI.

In an October statement, Orélien described the allegations as slander and heresy and said not a single sentence in the book was created by a machine. In the same statement he admitted plagiarism in earlier work, apologising for claiming as his own texts that were not his. The following week his Canadian publisher, Boréal, said new evidence showed AI had been used in the writing process, contrary to the author's repeated assurances, and ended its relationship with him.

Accusations of a double standard

The contrast between the two cases has prompted accusations of a racial double standard online, The Guardian reported. One user on X wrote that when it is an old white man it is fine, but when it is a young writer of colour he gets stoned in the public square. Another said Jaenada had faced no media lynching and no banishment over his use of AI, a leniency denied to Orélien.

Jaenada won on the first round of voting, by six votes to three over Sylvain Prudhomme's De l'autre côté du lac (The Other Side of the Lake). Shortlisted four times before, he has made a speciality of reinvestigating old French crimes; the winning book reconstructs the unsolved 1949 murder of Louise Cansot, a 29-year-old Breton artists' model known in Montparnasse as the woman with 100 portraits.

The prize comes with only a symbolic €10 cheque, but it is France's best known and most closely watched literary award. The Académie Goncourt, presided over by the novelist Philippe Claudel, has been approached for comment.

Sources

  1. Winner of the Prix Goncourt literary prize admits to using AI — The Guardian,

Every quotation and figure in this article is checked against the source reporting linked above before publication. How we report